Sunday, October 12, 2014

Close Reading: The Last Right

     In The Last Right: Why America Is Moving Slowly on Assisted Suicide, by Ross Douthat, the issue of committing doctor assisted suicide is examined. This topic has resurfaced in the news most recently with the Brittany Maynard story. This New York Times columnist uses diction, syntax, and details to effectively communicate his message to his readers. 
     Douthat uses diction throughout the article to establish a strong retort to this timely news. In paragraph one we read, "lethal prescription and die by suicide" (Douthat). The next section consists of the descriptive words such as suffering, terminal, pain, and suicide. In the third paragraph, Douthat writes, "The tragedy... a striking fact." The use of these words creates a sense of fear. In paragraph six, the word "fiercely" is used. These are a handful of Douthat's conscious word choices in his piece. 
     Another exceptional technique used by Douthat is the skillful use of syntax. From the beginning, we are educated on Brittany Maynard's story. This makes the article extremely  personable and relative to many. In paragraph three we are asked questions such as, "Why, in a society where individualism seems to be carrying the day, is the right that Maynard intends to exercise still confined to just a handful of states?" or "Why has assisted suicide’s advance been slow, when on other social issues the landscape has shifted dramatically in a libertarian direction?" These questions are thought-provoking and allow the reader an opportunity to contemplate what they will read in the upcoming paragraphs. The second half of the article presents legislative and political influences around assisted suicide.
    Douthat includes a multitude of details to inform us as readers on the history of doctor assisted suicide. He references that the "Supreme Court, which in 1997 ruled 9 to 0 that the Constitution does not include a right to suicide. (Douthat). We are additionally given the opportunity to reference an article posted that advocates for doctor assisted suicide.  Conservatives and liberal viewpoints are shared as well. Douthat writes that, 
"Many liberals seem considerably more uncomfortable with the idea of physician-assisted suicide than with other causes, from abortion to homosexuality, where claims about personal autonomy and liberty are at stake." to illustrate their side. For the opposition he states, "Conservatives oppose assisted suicide more fiercely." With these perspectives, we are able to make our own conclusions. 
     Throught this piece we are given an abundance of information on euthanasia. Ross Douthat provides us as readers with an abundance of evidence, allowing us to make our own choice. He effectively uses different types of rhetoric to convey the issue of doctor assisted suicide. 

4 comments:

  1. Hi Hunter,

    Very interesting article you've chosen. Ross Douthat (hehe it sounds like “do that” and he’s trying to convince people to do something) is trying to get convince people to support assisted suicide as a freedom people have. His diction and syntax here are key to his arguments as you have pointed out, since it’s such a moral conflict. He has to carefully say things in a way that doesn’t sound like doctors are killing patients by giving them the lethal drugs, but the patients are being relieved of their suffering with the doctors’ help.
    I am not absolutely sure, but I always thought imagery as something to be seen. Something physical like a decorated Christmas tree to be described. The references and supports you quoted seem more like details than imagery to me. Once again, I am not sure, so if you feel you are correct, then there’s nothing I can see that needs to be corrected with your blog post and great job.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Hunter! I really like how organized your post is! It was super easy to follow and that made your ideas easier to understand. One thing you might want to consider in the future is the title of the article itself. "The Last Right" implies that as citizens with many rights that we fight for, we also have the right to die. To Jeffery's point on imagery vs details, I think you just need to change it in your introductory paragraph since you did say details when you were talking about it in the rest of your post.
    Just a thought, but I think this issue isn't as big as other social issues probably because most of the people who support doctor assisted suicides are dead. Anyways, you did a really good job on this post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Very readable! Nice! Also, kudos for tackling such a controversial topic. A little more background on Maynard would be nice. I disagree with Kristen on the fact that assisted suicide supporters are mostly dead. It is a topic we debate in JSA on occasion, and there really is a good divide in opinion. I believe that the Diction paragraph, in particular, was well written and supported. Try to bring the others up to that level, if possible. Did you detect any bias on the part of the author? Or was he pretty neutral about the whole thing? Anyway, this was a very well-done paper. Good job.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hunter--I see a great deal of progress from Sept to Oct! I'd like to next see you working on being more specific about your thesis (what meaning, exactly, is the author trying to get across with all of those technique choices?) and being precise as you discuss how your examples support that thesis. Nice work, overall!

    ReplyDelete